Diverge.org

Links:

Diverge.Org

August 30, 2005

Disgruntled Asian-American Men

Filed under: Culture by bruxander

What if you were a genius in a jock world? Or just a smart, hard working man in a jock world? What if all the chicks assumed you’re a nerdy smartie of little social value because of your skin color? Maybe then you would become one of the Bitter Asian Men, “the site made by bitter asian men, for bitter asian men… and also for all of you out there who might be curious as to why we, as asian men, are so bitter.”

The site is boiling with reasoned anger about the place and role of Asian men in contemporary America. The site details several examples of how Asian men are hated on, so to speak, but I found the piece on Asian parents most interesting. Here’s an excerpt:

The first factor is the pressure. Oh, the pressure. If you think you know what parental pressure is, and you’re not Asian, you are wrong. Asian kids are consistently expected to do more and do better than their peers, and hell, even kids twice their age. Therefore, almost all Asian children 1) will play an instrument (a dignified classical instrument at that, and certainly not electric guitar) 2) will study math at an accelerated pace - I was doing calculus in middle school 3) will participate in as many extracurricular activities as possible (all academic though, never sports) and 4) take standardized tests early and as many times as necessary to achieve a perfect score.

Asian parents instill the notion of ‘you must succeed’ (by which they mean academic success, not social success) so early that by the time they reach high school, Asian kids are walking zombies reciting scientific facts like gospel. This problem is only exacerbated by the Asian trait (so common I swear it must be genetic) to compare children. Inevitably in any Asian child’s life, they will hear a line similar to “Why aren’t you taking calculus yet? Jim Wong’s son is a year younger than you and he is!”, or “You only got a 1550 on the SAT? Sally Lee’s daughter got a 1590!” or “What, you mean you’re not valedictorian!?” Though all Asian kids are driven by their parents to be geniuses, of course, only a few of them are actually capable of being geniuses. Those that aren’t live constantly under the vague impression that their parents wish their kids were better, while those who ARE, of course, live constantly under the vague impression that their parents believe they COULD be doing better.

Obviously such academic pressure leaves no time for a social life. Dating isn’t mentioned in the Asian household, and girls only come up as a topic of discussion if they’re horrifically smart and if your parents want to compare you to them. If dating is allowed, of course, the girlfriend must be Asian and must be smart (though not as smart as you, of course, as that would hurt the Family Honor). The end result is that Asian kids are disproportionately Book Smart over Street Smart. They can explain to you the Fundamental Theorem of Calculus but never grasp the fundamental rules of dating.

This complaint sounds like a Turbo-powered version of the ye olde Baby Boomers criticism of and eventual revolt against the bourgeois values that were so widespread in Europe and America until they were basically swept away by the Counter Culture in the 1960’s (more so in Europe than in America).

I really, really hope that Bitter Asian Men isn’t a prelude to a similar development among Asian Americans, because, damnit, we can’t afford to go through that kind of personal hedonism and societal waste again.

BAM’s feelings are understandble, though. Popular culture really does shaft Asian men, who rarely land movie roles as anything other than martial arts experts - not even as geeks, since Hollywood for some reason likes to cast African-Americans as computer experts. While Asians have made inroads in professional baseball in America, baseball itself has lost a good deal of its standing as America’s Sport, a role now carried by the National Football League, where, I believe, Dat Nguyen is the only Asian.

To add insult to injury, golf ace and self-described Cablanasian Tiger Woods is marketed exclusively as black in America.

Basically, America doesn’t allot much social status to areas which Asian men quite frankly dominate (such as computers) while it obsesses over those where Asian men do poorly (like football). Yet, as Bitter Asian Men points out, Asian females are coveted by whites. Why wouldn’t that piss you off if you were an Asian-American male? I know several interracial couples where the woman is Asian, but not a single one where the male is Asian (excluding a gay couple, for fairly obvious reasons).

(It should be noted that “Asian” in this context refers to Chinese, Japanese, Koreans, Vietnamese et al, and not to Indians, who, in American parlance, are lumped in with Asians. Interracial dating/coupling seems to be far less of a concern to Indians, and also far less common among them).

Part of the problem is that America is simply stuck in a Black and White worldview. Whites are the norm, Blacks are interesting and everybody else can essentially go screw. Or more to the point: There are people who are neither black nor white? How strange. The critically acclaimed, and in my opinion overrated, movie Crash spends a lot of energy on the Black/White divide, but treats Latinos and Asians as some kind of sideshow, even though Los Angeles, where the movie takes place, is 60% Asian and Latino. Considering that Asians and Latinos make up a rapidly growing proportion of America’s population, it could be in Mainstream America’s interest to pay them a little bit more attention.

From a national perspective, Asian American men present America with an intriguing dilemma: Should they assimilate into the less productive, more violent mainstream, or should they maintain their strenghts at the risk of further alienation?

5 Comments »

  1. I know asain american males that are hella macho dudes, one fellow police officer I know is Korean American guy, and he deadlifted a punk ass suspect that was pretty big sized, as though he (suspect) weighed nothing! I don’t see them as low on a social dating whatever scale!!Dude if parents force studies, shove studies up their ass, ok, and go play some frikkin football, or join the police dept. and use those martial arts skills to help our boys in blue! God bless th L.A.P.D!

    Comment by Abdul — October 29, 2005 @ 4:25 pm

  2. I do not see anything wrong with my asian lifestyle. I like my lifestyle and I think being uneducated is a terrible waste. Ever heard of the quote, “A mind is a terrible thing to waste.” You should study and be more open minded instead of thinking about when you are going to get a date. Or why you are not making enough money because you do not have a college degree.

    Comment by Chan — April 7, 2006 @ 4:41 am

  3. What the fuck are these two dickheads writing about! Abdul just fucking used an asian stereotype in his comment! martial fucking arts?!! and Chan should read more clearly what is written. the whole bitter asian men issue is not just about the projection of the stereotypical image of educated and martial arts expert asians. as an asian myself, i understand that asians need to express to the mainstream that we are more than the nerd, the kungfu sifu, or the guy you see when you can’t figure out a calculus problem. sure, be intelligent, be educated, take up martial arts…just do something else to break that stereotype because we are more than that and we know it.

    Comment by Gerikho — July 10, 2006 @ 3:48 am

  4. Wow, this is funny! Gerikho? I think I know you. As usual I agree with you. Definately my opinion is that Asians tend to get unusual coverage by the media. But things are changing. Anyway, my advice is just to serve Almighty God. I’m not kidding. Anything you want in life, just pray, with sincerity, and subservience to God. God is not White, or Asian, or Black or anything else, God is the supreme being for ALL PEOPLE who is greater than anything we can possibly imagine. One day I was sitting in my room, and I prayed a peculiar prayer, but sincerely nonetheless, for God to introduce a girl who is Black or is mixed with Black and White, who is beautiful in my eyes, and will take care of me for the rest of my life (y’know us guys need help in the kitchen and cleaning and massaging of our feet when we’re tired from work - just kidding ladies). Anyway, that someone I felt I would be most happy with. Soon after that, I met a girl on the bus who is 3/4 White, and 1/4 Black, and the most beautiful girl I ever saw. Since then, she told me she wants to take care of me for the rest of my life, and now we’re engaged to get married and just got our wedding bands. It’s a peculiar story, but it’s real. I’m Korean by the way. If anyone out there who wants to be a great Asian-American actor to touch the lives of millions of Americans, and portray the real lives and dreams of Asian-Americans, then get on your knees, serve and worship God, and pray. If you’re waiting for a Messiah to come out from Asia, just remember that Confucius, and Laotzu of Taoism, say many of the same things as Jesus. Please pray for me as I will audition for acting school, and because I am an aspiring singer-songwriter. Pray for yourselves, thank God, and don’t forget to praise God; God is listening. Just repeat “Praise God!” or something like that with all your heart and mind and soul. God likes that things like that. Remember God loves all his children. God be praised!

    Comment by Mikey — July 23, 2006 @ 6:30 am

  5. Mikey’s story is exactly what I needed to hear. I have always been especially attracted to Asian men, and after learning about Korean culture from a Korean ex boyfriend, I decided I had to come to Seoul. I am currently living and studying Korean language in Seoul. I’ve been praying for a handsome (Yu Ji Tae like) Christian Korean to come in to my life, some one I can take care of, and someone to care for me. I’ve been here five months, and I feel more than comfortable living in Korea and being a part of it’s culture.
    However, while almost all my friends have met someone, I am still by myself.
    It seems like the only men here who are attracted to me are the ajossi’s, the older men. I can tell some guys my age are attracted to me but they never say anything. I cant seem to figure out why. I wonder, but I hope it’s not true, if it’s because I’m black? I’m not unattractive (I cant tell you how many times an ajossi has told me I’m pretty). And I come from a good family (my father is a doctor) from the suburbs, and I strive to life my life in a way that God will be pleased, and I try to always be compassionate (growing up as the only minority in a white surburb, I really had to learn to understand people and be compassionate and forgiving).
    Anyway, as much as I love it here, and as much as I want to spend the rest of my life in this beautiful city, sometimes it’s hard for me, especially since my friends have gone back to the states, or are travelling or working. Lately, it has been really hard…. then while browsing the internet I come across this comment and my heart and mind were reminded of somethings that I had forgotten in my yearning. So thanks, and I’ll pray for you– will you please pray for me to?
    Erica

    Comment by Erica — July 25, 2006 @ 9:06 am

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment